Create an Account
username: password:
 
  MemeStreams Logo

MemeStreams Discussion

search


This page contains all of the posts and discussion on MemeStreams referencing the following web page: Unused Audio Commentary By Howard Zinn & Noam Chomsky, Recorded Summer, 2002, for The Fellowship of the Ring (Platinum Series Extended Edition) DVD, Part Two. You can find discussions on MemeStreams as you surf the web, even if you aren't a MemeStreams member, using the Threads Bookmarklet.

Unused Audio Commentary By Howard Zinn & Noam Chomsky, Recorded Summer, 2002, for The Fellowship of the Ring (Platinum Series Extended Edition) DVD, Part Two
by BridgetAG at 11:43 pm EDT, May 22, 2003

This is absolutely the driest humor I have ever come across. Two parts, slightly dated to winter of last year but spot on humor. Don't miss the analysis of the instabilities inherent in The Shire's pipe-weed based economy in Part 1.

] Chomsky: Is there any kind of idea that men should live
] in peace with the Orcs?
]
]
] Zinn: Think of the scenes in the prologue with all the
] arrows hitting these thousands of Orcs. We're supposed to
] think that this is a good thing.
]
]
] Chomsky: I think this is a tragedy, this story. Because
] it's about two cultures. And poor leadership. It's a
] human tragedy, and an Orcish tragedy.


'Unused' Commentary on The Fellowship of the Ring - Is peace with the orcs possible?
by Elonka at 1:35 pm EDT, May 23, 2003

Satirical "commentary" about the Fellowship of the Ring, from a different perspective on Good and Evil.

In this commentary, Frodo is a Mohammed Atta character being sent on a suicide mission, the elves are militaristic genocide-mongers who are promoting an orc apartheid, the Black Riders are "misunderstood", the orcs are fighting a war of self-defense against the invading Fellowship, and Gandalf is a dictator attempting to control the media . . .

] This takes me back to the media's involvement in all
] this, and the way the media is being controlled by
] Gandalf, such as when he covers Saruman's palantir in
] Orthanc. This is the stone that allows one to see, and
] thus communicate with, different cultures.

Question everything. ;)


'Unused' Commentary on The Fellowship of the Ring - Is peace with the orcs possible?
by Lost at 8:30 pm EDT, May 23, 2003

] Chomsky: Naturally, it's in Rohan/Gondor's interest to
] keep the Orcs obscured, to make everything as restricted
] and dehumanizing as possible. It's always the first step
] toward genocide. And is this %u2014 is there anything
] less than genocide being advocated in this film?
]
] Zinn: I don't think so.
]
] Chomsky: Is there any kind of idea that men should live
] in peace with the Orcs?


There are redundant posts not displayed in this view from the following users: Andy, agarhti.
 
 
Powered By Industrial Memetics