Create an Account
username: password:
 
  MemeStreams Logo

Alito

search

Decius
Picture of Decius
Decius's Pics
My Blog
My Profile
My Audience
My Sources
Send Me a Message

sponsored links

Decius's topics
Arts
  Literature
   Sci-Fi/Fantasy Literature
  Movies
   Sci-Fi/Fantasy Films
  Music
   Electronic Music
Business
  Finance & Accounting
  Tech Industry
  Telecom Industry
  Management
  Markets & Investing
Games
Health and Wellness
Home and Garden
  Parenting
Miscellaneous
  Humor
  MemeStreams
Current Events
  War on Terrorism
Recreation
  Cars and Trucks
  Travel
Local Information
  United States
   SF Bay Area
    SF Bay Area News
Science
  Biology
  History
  Math
  Nano Tech
  Physics
Society
  Economics
  Politics and Law
   Civil Liberties
    Internet Civil Liberties
    Surveillance
   Intellectual Property
  Media
   Blogging
Sports
Technology
  Computer Security
  Macintosh
  Spam
  High Tech Developments

support us

Get MemeStreams Stuff!


 
Alito
Topic: Current Events 3:21 am EST, Nov 21, 2005

The justice system is a human system, and so it is inevitable that the justice system fails. The justice system punishes innocent people.

With respect to the death penalty, the execution of innocents may be very rare. However, it is inevitable. So we must understand that if we are to support the death penalty we must accept that innocent people will die as a result, even if only very rarely.

For me to allow the state to proceed with an imperfect system which creates permanent results, I would need to have compelling evidence that the cost was worth the reward in terms of the innocent lives saved. No such evidence exists. In fact there are substantive arguments that the death penalty contributes to the rate of violent crime rather then deterring it. It isn't clear that the death penalty works, and so how can you proceed...

One would hope you would proceed with extreme caution, but the attitude expressed by Alito that the Constitution only provides for reasonable defense and that substantive information about a capital case which was missed by that defense does not warrant retrial advocates a wanton attitude about such grave matters and is precisely likely to contribute to a situation in which innocent people are more likely to be executed.

This isn't acceptable. I'm growing less comfortable with Alito. But I have another problem.

The conservatives are not going to nominate a justice with an intelligent point of view on the death penalty. In light of that do I need to accept this and find other grounds upon which to consider his nomination (which is exactly what I advocated that abortion rights advocates do here)? Perhaps so.

Needless to say, on both counts, moderate Republican voters ought to really think about what they've purchased by re-electing Bush. I remain unconvinced that the impact that this election is having on the court is less important, long term, then the likely differences between a Republican and Democratic strategy on the war on terror going forward. I owe a hat tip for that observation to Rattle.



 
 
Powered By Industrial Memetics
RSS2.0