Create an Account
username: password:
 
  MemeStreams Logo

MemeStreams Discussion

search


This page contains all of the posts and discussion on MemeStreams referencing the following web page: Who Needs Hackers?. You can find discussions on MemeStreams as you surf the web, even if you aren't a MemeStreams member, using the Threads Bookmarklet.

Who Needs Hackers?
by noteworthy at 11:38 pm EDT, Sep 13, 2007

“Many times the problems you see that you try to correct are not the root causes of the problem,” he said.

We could be talking about a lot of things, but in this case, this is the CIO for the US Customs Agency, and he is talking about a faulty NIC at LAX.


 
RE: Who Needs Hackers?
by Decius at 12:09 pm EDT, Sep 14, 2007

noteworthy wrote:

“Many times the problems you see that you try to correct are not the root causes of the problem,” he said.

We could be talking about a lot of things, but in this case, this is the CIO for the US Customs Agency, and he is talking about a faulty NIC at LAX.

I'm really growing tired of the use of the word "hacker" in this context. I talk about computer security issues with industry and the press on nearly a daily basis and I never, ever use the word hacker. It is deeply misleading to use the word hacker when you mean to say "computer intruder" or "computer criminal."

I recently saw an FBI agent present on computer security issues and it was "hacker" this and "hacker" that for 20 odd minutes. I came very close to saying something to him about it. Its like saying "hippie" when you mean to say "drug trafficers." Eastern European payment card fraud rings and Southeast Asian industrial spies have as much to do with "hackers" as Columbian narcoterrorists have to do with "hippies." By using the word "hacker" instead of using the word "computer criminal" the FBI makes it sounds as if they aren't really focused on computer crime so much as they are focused on people whose politics they don't like.

I think there is a need here for a website, perhaps organized as a non-profit, with form letters that people can send news media organizations that use the word "hacker" in a context that has nothing to do with the computer subculture that word refers to, and which has the ultimately goal of getting the AP style guide modified to prohibit the use of the word hacker where "computer intruder" or "computer criminal" is more appropriate, and includes a lot of text explaining where Eric Raymond went wrong in attempting to resolve this previously.


  
RE: Who Needs Hackers?
by noteworthy at 3:22 pm EDT, Sep 14, 2007

Decius wrote:

I'm really growing tired of the use of the word "hacker" in this context.

Consider starting with a letter to the editor, or perhaps a letter to the Public Editor at the New York Times. In the past, the Public Editor has investigated the paper's usage of terms like "suicide bomber", "martyr", "terrorist", "insurgent", "freedom fighter", etc.

Also, you can Send an E-Mail to John Schwartz. He might be receptive to a friendly note on the subject.


   
RE: Who Needs Hackers?
by Decius at 8:28 am EDT, Sep 15, 2007

noteworthy wrote:
Decius wrote:

I'm really growing tired of the use of the word "hacker" in this context.

Consider starting with a letter to the editor, or perhaps a letter to the Public Editor at the New York Times. In the past, the Public Editor has investigated the paper's usage of terms like "suicide bomber", "martyr", "terrorist", "insurgent", "freedom fighter", etc.

Also, you can Send an E-Mail to John Schwartz. He might be receptive to a friendly note on the subject.

I think its gunna take more than a friendly email to unfuck 30 years of ignorance. They'll investigate the proper use of terms like "insugent" because its important to maintain balance when talking about groups that are powerful. The hacker subculture is neither as important nor as powerful as Hamas, and so the press does not feel that they need to be handled objectively or fairly.


    
RE: Who Needs Hackers?
by ubernoir at 9:09 am EDT, Sep 15, 2007

Decius wrote:

noteworthy wrote:
Decius wrote:

I'm really growing tired of the use of the word "hacker" in this context.

Consider starting with a letter to the editor, or perhaps a letter to the Public Editor at the New York Times. In the past, the Public Editor has investigated the paper's usage of terms like "suicide bomber", "martyr", "terrorist", "insurgent", "freedom fighter", etc.

Also, you can Send an E-Mail to John Schwartz. He might be receptive to a friendly note on the subject.

I think its gunna take more than a friendly email to unfuck 30 years of ignorance. They'll investigate the proper use of terms like "insugent" because its important to maintain balance when talking about groups that are powerful. The hacker subculture is neither as important nor as powerful as Hamas, and so the press does not feel that they need to be handled objectively or fairly.

but the word hacker does make a rather nice Shibboleth though!


There is a redundant post from Dagmar not displayed in this view.
 
 
Powered By Industrial Memetics